How an Emoji Can Ruin Your Entire Nervous System
By Helene Waters
Dating in your forties is a completely different experience to dating at eighteen.
Since deciding to enter the world of dating after my husband passed away, I’ve realised something important:
This is not fun.
I have only dipped my toe into the dating world twice.
Two attempts.
Neither showed any real promise of intimacy.
And honestly?
Probably a good thing.
One man was slightly less divorced than he originally claimed to be.
Another was emotionally tangled up in an ex and I suspect I accidentally became some sort of rebound therapist with WiFi access.
Neither lasted very long.
One was a record-breaking three weeks.
The other lasted four months.
Both spectacularly imploded with the grace and dignity of a shopping trolley being pushed off a cliff by an angry toddler.
More recently, a man openly admitted that he likes “a challenge” after I declined his offer of a “see where it goes” relationship while his wife sat at home existing very much as his wife.
I would rather rip off my own arm and beat myself with the wet end than get involved with a married man.
At eighteen, you are mostly operating on optimism, hormones, bad judgement and the belief that emotional devastation only happens to “other people.”
In your forties?
You arrive carrying enough emotional baggage to qualify for excess luggage fees at international airports.
Some of us arrive with enough baggage to require a second aircraft and special clearance from Air Traffic Control.
And unfortunately, so does everybody else.
Nobody Warns You How Awkward This Is
Nobody tells you how deeply awkward it feels trying to re-enter the world of attraction after decades of actual life happening to you.
Divorce.
Widowhood.
Betrayal.
Children.
Financial stress.
Health problems.
Grief.
Gaslighting.
Therapy.
Trauma.
And the slow realisation that your knees now make sounds that should probably be investigated medically.
At this point, when you stand up, your joints click like two Xhosa women fighting over Tupperware lids after Christmas lunch.
At eighteen, flirting feels exciting.
In your forties, flirting feels like submitting a vulnerable emotional thesis for peer review.
You analyse everything.
Message length.
Punctuation.
Response times.
Emoji selection.
Particularly emoji selection.
At this age, even a mildly ambiguous response can have you analysing your phone like an FBI profiler investigating emotional evidence.
A heart means one thing.
A thumbs-up feels vaguely hostile.
The sparkle emoji? He probably finds you entertaining.
The smiling blush emoji? Mild attraction with plausible deniability.
The weak smile emoji? He’s responding, but spiritually he has already left the building.
One slightly delayed response and suddenly you’re chewing your nails down to the beds while convincing yourself you’ve somehow become emotionally overbearing because you sent two messages too close together three business days ago.
You spend three hours drafting a message.
Delete it.
Rewrite it.
Remove one emoji because it feels emotionally aggressive.
Add an emoji because without it you sound emotionally unavailable.
Read it fourteen times.
Press send.
Immediately wish you had emigrated instead.
My mind was not designed for this level of psychological warfare.
I’m intelligent, mouthy, sarcastic and reasonably capable of navigating adult life.
I can teach thirty children.
I can manage a classroom.
I can negotiate with mechanics.
I can survive grief.
What I apparently cannot do is determine the emotional significance of a thumbs-up emoji sent at 10:47 PM on a Wednesday.
Attraction Changes Completely
Dating in your forties is strange because attraction no longer works the same way either.
At eighteen, attraction is often immediate and uncomplicated.
“He’s hot.”
“She’s pretty.”
Done.
By forty, attraction becomes deeply psychological.
You fall for voices.
Minds.
Kindness.
Humour.
Emotional safety.
The way someone speaks about their children.
The way they speak about themselves.
The way they make you feel calm instead of confused.
And somehow, that feels far more terrifying.
Because physical attraction bruises the ego.
Emotional attraction exposes the soul.
At this age, most people are not afraid of being alone forever.
They are afraid of being emotionally destroyed again.
That changes everything.
You become cautious.
You tell yourself things like:
“I’m not looking for anything serious.”
“I’m fine on my own.”
“I don’t even want to date.”
Then somebody unexpectedly intelligent with a beautiful voice and emotionally dangerous levels of self-awareness appears and suddenly your entire nervous system collapses like a potjie pot balanced incorrectly over the coals.
Which feels deeply unfair, honestly.
People like this should come with warning labels and government-issued permits.
The Platonic Friend Who Suddenly Becomes a Relationship Expert
One of the funniest things about adulthood is discovering that people who have never actually lived your life suddenly become experts on it.
A years-long, completely platonic male friend once decided it was very important to explain my dating problems to me.
Apparently my boundaries were the problem.
Apparently wanting honesty was “too much”.
Apparently if I had just been more willing to “put out”, things might have gone differently.
Ah yes.
The ancient wisdom of:
“Have fewer standards and maybe people will like you.”
A revolutionary concept.
Right alongside:
“Wear a helmet backwards and maybe you’ll see better.”
Some people confuse boundaries with walls.
They confuse self-respect with being difficult.
They confuse a woman knowing her worth with a woman being unavailable.
But here is the thing:
If someone only likes you when you have no boundaries, they do not like you.
They like access.
There is a difference.
Dating as a Widow
There is also something deeply strange about dating as a widow.
People hear the word “widow” and often seem to make immediate assumptions.
Some men blatantly assume you are looking for financial support or someone to rescue you emotionally.
Others become intimidated by your independence because surviving profound loss tends to force a person to become capable in ways they never planned to be.
And somehow, existing somewhere in the middle seems to confuse people most of all.
Because I am not helpless.
I can fix a plug.
I can change the oil in my car.
Replace a tyre.
Bargain with a mechanic.
Unclog a toilet.
The only reason I can’t change a light bulb is because I’m five foot two and don’t own a ladder tall enough.
But I am also not untouched.
I have survived grief.
That changes a person.
Not into someone weak.
Not into someone broken.
Just someone far more aware of how fragile life and love really are.
We Are All Pretending
There is also the humiliating reality that most adults secretly have no idea what they are doing anymore.
We are all pretending.
Underneath the composed adult exterior is usually someone thinking:
“Was that message too much?”
“Do I sound desperate?”
“Should I wait before replying?”
“Was that flirting or were they just being polite?”
“Have I accidentally become emotionally attached because someone remembered my favourite tea?”
Nobody knows.
We are all just emotionally concussed adults trying our best.
And then there is the baggage.
Everybody has it.
The person sitting across from you at coffee may look calm and put together, but internally they are likely carrying heartbreak, disappointment, abandonment, insecurity, grief, regret, fear and at least one relationship that permanently altered their brain chemistry.
Dating at this age means understanding that people are not blank slates anymore.
We are novels already half-written.
Some chapters are beautiful.
Some are traumatic.
Some should probably be set on fire.
The Bedtime Problem
Another thing nobody warns you about is bedtime.
At eighteen, if someone suggested meeting at 10 PM, that sounded exciting.
At forty-six, if someone suggests meeting at 10 PM, my first question is:
“At night?”
Because that is dangerously close to bedtime.
I have a routine now.
I have coffee and if I’m feeling flat, herbal tea.
I have a blanket.
I have crime documentaries, journalling, books and blog ideas to build on.
I have a fluffy hound who firmly believes cuddles are mandatory.
I have absolutely no interest in starting an emotional journey after 9 PM.
If romance cannot occur between breakfast and a sensible evening meal, I may no longer have the energy required.
Honestly, the older I get, the more I suspect the real dating profile should read:
Seeking emotionally mature companion.
Must be more appealing than:
- My bed
- My tea
- My dog
- My books
- Being left alone
The Real Reason It Feels So Hard
Perhaps the strangest part of dating later in life is this:
Vulnerability becomes both harder and more meaningful.
At eighteen, you risk embarrassment.
At forty, you risk reopening wounds you fought incredibly hard to survive.
And yet…
something inside many of us still wants connection anyway.
Not perfection.
Not fantasy.
Not constant excitement.
Just connection.
Someone safe enough to laugh with.
Talk to.
Sit quietly beside.
Send memes to.
Share ordinary life with.
Someone whose presence feels less like performance and more like peace.
And maybe that is why dating in your forties feels so emotionally complicated.
Because by this stage of life, people are no longer looking for someone to complete them.
They are looking for someone gentle enough not to destroy the parts they fought so hard to rebuild.
Cheese & Jam 
Leave a comment